Practical planning tools for short growing seasons.
Climate-based onion planting guide for Malone, New York
When to Plant Onions in Malone
Onions are usually a comfortable fit in Malone. The season is generally supportive enough that consistency, sizing, and harvest goals matter more than season pressure.
Typical Planting Window
Excellent fit in this climate
Use the planting dates below for onions in Malone.
Start indoors
February 18
Typical planting windowApril 15 – April 29
MethodTransplant
Typical days to maturity95–110
Onions are usually started indoors around February 18 and planted outdoors during the normal local window of April 15 to April 29.
Most varieties need about 95–110 days to reach maturity once they are in the garden.
Onions are usually a comfortable fit in Malone. Gardeners usually get the best results when they use that margin to improve finish quality and uniformity.
Even here, the climate does not guarantee an even finish. The better results still come from steady growth, consistent sizing, and harvesting when the crop is actually ready.
Best local strategy:
Plant in the normal window and use the extra margin to focus on steady growth, plant health, and finishing cleanly.
Can Onions Mature in Malone?
Growing degree days measure how much useful warmth typically accumulates during the season. For onions, this helps estimate whether local heat accumulation is usually enough for the crop to reach maturity on time.
Available GDD (base 45)2820
Typical crop GDD target1300
Heat margin+1520
From the usual planting window, Malone typically provides about 2820 growing degree days for onions. With a typical crop target of 1300, that leaves a heat margin of +1520. That large heat margin means season length is usually not the limiting issue here. The more useful question is how gardeners use that room to improve sizing, finish quality, and harvest timing.
When Is It Too Late to Plant?
If planting later than usual, this table shows how much growing degree day heat is still available from each point in the season. For onions, it is most useful for judging how much freedom you still have to plant for quality, finish, and harvest goals as the season moves along.
Checkpoint
Remaining GDD
Heat margin
Fit vs typical target
Apr 15
2898
+1598
Comfortable
May 1
2877
+1577
Comfortable
May 15
2774
+1474
Comfortable
Jun 1
2556
+1256
Comfortable
Jun 15
2309
+1009
Comfortable
Jul 1
1966
+666
Comfortable
How Different Onion Varieties Affect Results
Most onion varieties can succeed in Malone in a typical year. That gives gardeners room to choose for the kind of harvest they want, not just for minimum maturity speed.
Varieties that often fit well here include:
Walla Walla
— large and popular, but still best when started early enough to build size
Copra
— a dependable storage onion with good all-around practicality
Redwing
— a strong red storage type where the season is reasonably supportive
Patterson
— a solid keeping onion that wants enough runway to size up well
Ailsa Craig
— more exposed in shorter seasons because it benefits from a longer finishing run
Best Onion Varieties for Malone
Mid-season onion varieties are usually the strongest all-around match in Malone. The local season can support onions, so the main choice is usually about bulb size, sweetness, color, and keeping quality.
May 6
local season starts
October 4
frost pressure returns
Less heat used2820 GDD available
Hover or tap the dots to see which recommended varieties use that much local heat.
For Malone, start with Redwing and Patterson for onions when you want red storage onions or long-keeping onions.
Choose Walla Walla when you want large sweet onions.
Look at Ailsa Craig and Copra when you specifically want large exhibition onions or dependable storage onions.
Compare each variety’s heat need and maturity timing against the local frost-free window before choosing what to grow.
Recommended starting point
RedwingMid-season
1300 GDD needed2820 available before frost
May 6October 4
Comfortable fit
Why this fit?
Local season fit:
Redwing leaves about 1520 GDD cushion against the normal Malone crop heat estimate.
Best for: red storage onions.
A strong red onion that makes sense where the season is supportive enough for good bulb sizing.
Tradeoff: Needs a supportive season for good bulb sizing.
PattersonMid-season
1300 GDD needed2820 available before frost
May 6October 4
Comfortable fit
Why this fit?
Local season fit:
Patterson leaves about 1520 GDD cushion against the normal Malone crop heat estimate.
Best for: long-keeping onions.
A solid keeping onion that wants enough runway to size up well before the season closes.
Tradeoff: Needs enough runway before the season closes.
Fastest / most cushion
Walla WallaVery early
1100 GDD needed2820 available before frost
May 6October 4
Comfortable fit
Why this fit?
Local season fit:
Walla Walla leaves about 1720 GDD cushion against the normal Malone crop heat estimate.
Best for: large sweet onions.
A large, popular onion that can be rewarding, but still needs an early enough start to build size.
Tradeoff: Needs an early enough start to build size.
Also realistic
Ailsa CraigLate
1400 GDD needed2820 available before frost
May 6October 4
Comfortable fit
Why this fit?
Local season fit:
Ailsa Craig leaves about 1420 GDD cushion against the normal Malone crop heat estimate.
Best for: large exhibition onions.
A large onion that is more exposed in shorter seasons because it benefits from a longer finishing run.
Tradeoff: More exposed in shorter seasons.
CopraEarly
1200 GDD needed2820 available before frost
May 6October 4
Comfortable fit
Why this fit?
Local season fit:
Copra leaves about 1620 GDD cushion against the normal Malone crop heat estimate.
Best for: dependable storage onions.
A practical storage onion with good all-around usefulness when started early.
Tradeoff: Still needs enough season to size up.
GDD comparisons are a planning shortcut, not a guarantee. Soil, watering, sowing depth, pests, transplant quality, and harvest goals still affect the final result.
Variety class
Typical days to maturity
Typical GDD need
Local fit
Very early
90–95
1100
Good fit
Early
95–105
1200
Good fit
Mid-season
105–115
1300
Good fit
Late
115–120
1400
Good fit
Main risk: The usual setbacks here come from management choices rather than from the season itself.
How Frost Affects Planting Dates for Onions in Malone
Malone usually has about 151 frost-free days, with a typical last spring frost around May 6 and a typical first fall frost around October 4.
Typical last spring frostMay 6
Typical first fall frostOctober 4
Typical frost-free days151
Minimum safe temperature28°F /
-2
°C
Onions are generally
lightly frost tolerant
and temperatures below about 28°F (
-2
°C) can slow growth or damage plants.
Onions are usually tolerant enough of cool conditions that frost dates act more like planning markers than hard limits. In practice, timing and steady early growth matter more than avoiding every light frost.
The most common problems here are not climatic ones. Gardeners usually lose ground through timing, uneven growth, or letting the crop move past its best stage.
In Malone, onions usually have a solid seasonal margin when planted around April 15. The warmest garden spots are usually south-facing walls, sheltered gardens, raised beds, and sunnier urban lots. Cooler spots like low spots, exposed sites, and shadier yards tend to warm up later and usually provide less heat. For onions, warmer garden spots usually improve early growth and can make timing a little more forgiving.
Set up onions for sizing, watering, and storage
The biggest gains usually come from better planting setup, steady moisture, good sizing, and clean harvest handling rather than season extension.
Soil and planting setup
For storage crops, the best gains usually come from strong early growth and a clean finish.